Advanced English Lab

Learn English in a Better Way

Latest
Grammar

Modal Verbs in English: Obligation, Permission and Deduction

How to use must, have to, mustn't, don't have to, can, may, might and can't for obligation, permission and deduction, in the present and the past.

Teacher explaining three rules for modal verbs on a classroom whiteboard with examples of correct and incorrect modal verb usage
Teacher explaining three rules for modal verbs on a classroom whiteboard with examples of correct and incorrect modal verb usage

Modal verbs (can, could, may, might, must, shall, should, will, would) add meaning to a main verb: obligation, permission, possibility or certainty. This lesson covers the three areas where learners make the most mistakes. Separate lessons cover can/could and should in detail.

Three grammar rules for all modals

  1. A modal is followed by the base verb without to: She can swim. (✗ can to swim, ✗ can swims)
  2. Modals never add -s: He must go. (✗ he musts)
  3. Questions and negatives need no do: Can you help? You mustn’t park here.

Obligation: must, have to, mustn’t, don’t have to

FormMeaningExample
muststrong obligation, often from the speakerI must call my mother tonight.
have toobligation from outside (rules, laws, situations)Students have to wear a uniform.
mustn’tit is forbiddenYou mustn’t use your phone in the exam.
don’t have toit is not necessary (you can choose)You don’t have to come if you’re busy.

Mustn’t and don’t have to are completely different. You mustn’t pay means paying is not allowed; you don’t have to pay means it is free.

Must has no past form. For past obligation, use had to: I had to wait two hours.

Permission: can, could, may

AskingGivingRefusing
Can I use your pen? (informal)Yes, you can.No, you can’t.
Could I leave early today? (polite)Yes, of course.I’m afraid not.
May I come in? (formal)Yes, you may.No, you may not.

Deduction: how sure are you?

We also use modals to say how certain we are that something is true, based on evidence.

CertaintyPresentPast (modal + have + past participle)
about 100% sure it is trueShe must be tired. (she worked all night)She must have been tired.
possibleHe might / may / could be at home.He might have missed the bus.
about 100% sure it is not trueThat can’t be Rahim; he’s in London.You can’t have seen him; he was abroad.

The opposite of must be (deduction) is can’t be, not mustn’t be.

Common mistakes

WrongRight
You must to submit it today.You must submit it today.
She cans speak French.She can speak French.
Yesterday I must work late.Yesterday I had to work late.
You mustn’t come; it’s optional.You don’t have to come; it’s optional.
He mustn’t be at home; the lights are off.He can’t be at home; the lights are off.

Practice

  1. In Bangladesh, you ___ drive on the left. (rule)
  2. You ___ smoke in the hospital. (forbidden)
  3. You ___ bring food; lunch is provided.
  4. Last year I ___ (work) on Saturdays.
  5. The ground is wet. It ___ (rain) last night.
  6. Don’t worry, she ___ (be) stuck in traffic. (possible)
  7. He ___ be the thief. He was with me all evening.
  8. ___ I borrow your notes? (polite)
Show answers and explanations
  1. have to: an external rule.
  2. mustn’t: forbidden.
  3. don’t have to: not necessary.
  4. had to work: past of must/have to.
  5. must have rained: past deduction, certain.
  6. might/may/could be: possibility.
  7. can’t: certain it is not true.
  8. Could / May: polite permission.

References